Case files2 min read
Case file: the Netflix price split, and the 800,000 subscribers it cost
In July 2011 Netflix split DVD and streaming into two plans. One quarter later it had 800,000 fewer US subscribers. What the reaction tells every company planning a price change.
On 12 July 2011, Netflix announced that DVD-by-mail and streaming would no longer be sold together. Customers who had paid $9.99 a month for both would now pay $7.99 for each — $15.98 for the same service, a rise of 60%.
On paper the logic was sound. Streaming was the future, DVD was expensive to run, and separating the two let the company price each on its own merits. The reaction was not on paper.
What happened
- July 2011: the split and the new prices are announced. The announcement draws tens of thousands of angry comments within days.
- September 2011: Netflix announces that the DVD business will become a separate brand, Qwikster, with its own website and account.
- October 2011: Qwikster is cancelled about three weeks later. The price split stays.
- Q3 2011: Netflix reports that it lost about 800,000 US subscribers in the quarter.
By late November, the share price had fallen by roughly three quarters from its July high. The company recovered and went on to dominate streaming, but the episode became the standard example of a price change that was announced before it was understood.
Three lessons for any price change
1. The size of the rise was not the whole story. Customers were also asked to make a choice they had never had to make, between two services they thought of as one. A change that adds a decision for the customer creates a moment to leave.
2. The old price was the anchor. Customers did not compare $15.98 with what competitors charged. They compared it with the $9.99 they had paid last month. The reference point for any price change is the customer's own history.
3. Framing doubled the damage. The Qwikster announcement, meant to explain the split, made the change feel larger and more permanent. How a change is described moves the reaction as much as the number does.
What testing first would have shown
None of these reactions needed a launch to discover. Which segments would leave rather than complain, how the change would be read against the old price, whether a second brand would help or hurt: these are questions that can be put to a market before the announcement goes out.
That is the work Preditance does. A team describes the change; a grounded panel of customers, competitors and regulators reacts; the team gets a verdict, the segments that resist, and safer variants that keep the intent, such as a longer notice period, grandfathering for long-standing members, or a single plan with a smaller increase.
Sources: Netflix shareholder letters and public announcements, July–October 2011. This case file describes public events; it is not a Preditance simulation.
Planning a price change of your own? Test it with two free clearances.